SAN FRANCISCO/WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The Texas attorney general’s office has hired three consultants for a multi-state probe it is leading into Alphabet Inc’s Google, including an economist who worked with some of the firm’s major rivals and a lawyer who is a Microsoft veteran.
FILE PHOTO: Visitors pass by the logo of Google at the high profile startups and high tech leaders gathering, Viva Tech,in Paris, France May 16, 2019. REUTERS/Charles Platiau/File Photo
A group of 48 state attorneys general, joined by Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico, announced this month that they were investigating accusations of antitrust violations by search and advertising giant Google, one of several focused on tech firms.
The three consultants are Roger Alford, until this year a deputy assistant attorney general in the Justice Department’s antitrust division; Eugene Burrus, an external adviser at McKinsey & Co who was assistant general counsel at Microsoft Corp; and Cristina Caffarra, an economist heading the European competition team at consultancy Charles River Associates.
“Everyone knows this will be a long-running investigation,” said Alford, who has taught law at the University of Notre Dame since 2012. He told Reuters that meetings on the matter began in August but declined to comment further.
Texas’ contracts with Alford and Burrus – seen by Reuters on Wednesday through a public records request – ran from May 29 through Aug. 31, with a maximum hourly fee of $500 and an optional extension. Alford said his contract had been extended through Aug. 31, 2021.
Caffarra’s contract runs from Sept. 3 to Aug. 31, 2021 with maximum fees of $0.
Marc Rylander, a spokesman for Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, said in statement that “as we often do, the state has acquired legal consulting experts for this ongoing investigation.”
Google, which has said it is cooperating with investigators, declined to comment.
Burrus spent 15 years at Microsoft before joining law firm Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro in 2017 for a short stint. It has represented clients in antitrust and other lawsuits against Google, and his firm biography says he developed an antitrust case that led the EU to fine Google $2.7 billion for its shopping tool in 2017. McKinsey said Burrus’ work for the states’ investigation is in his personal capacity.
A spokesman for Microsoft, which has complained about Google’s competitive tactics, did not provide immediate comment.
Caffarra, standing among several attorneys general this month at a news conference for the Google investigation, posted on Twitter that the announcement was “a huge deal.”
Alford said he was also at the event.
Though Caffarra’s contract with Texas calls for her to earn no money, a slide presentation from August posted on the Charles River website lists Google critic News Corp and competitors Microsoft and Amazon.com Inc among her clients on antitrust matters.
Caffarra told Reuters on Thursday that she decided to work pro bono for the states’ investigation after Nebraska Attorney General Doug Peterson approached her.
“My position is that when working for a government body, I don’t need to do anything besides work pro bono,” she said. “I am not funded by anyone adverse to Google right now.”
As part of its investigation, the Texas AG’s office has sought information from Oracle Corp, its executive vice president, Ken Glueck, told Reuters on Wednesday.
Oracle has feuded with Google over several business issues, and was involved in advocacy group FairSearch that pushed for the European Union to investigate Google.
Oracle has also heard from the House Judiciary Committee, Glueck said, and has met the Justice Department.
The Federal Trade Commission and several states led by New York’s attorney general have confirmed antitrust investigations into Facebook Inc.
The FTC is also looking at Amazon, sources have said. The Justice Department has launched a broad review of large internet companies.
Reporting by Paresh Dave in San Francisco and Diane Bartz in Washington; Editing by Greg Mitchell, Clarence Fernandez and Lisa Shumaker